News Entrepreneurship Business Entertainment Features Covers

Copyright Office Protects Only Human Authorship in AI Works, Citing Its March 2023 Guidance

The U.S. Copyright Office protects only human authorship in AI-assisted works, examines what people contribute to AI output, and issued registration guidance in March 2023.

Technology By Ryan Delgado | | 5 min read
Copyright Office Protects Only Human Authorship in AI Works, Citing Its March 2023 Guidance

Founders who use generative AI to draft copy, design a logo or produce images often ask whether the result can be registered with the U.S. Copyright Office. The answer depends on how much of the finished work a person created. The Office’s position rests on one principle: copyright protects human authorship.

The Office set out its view in a January 2025 report and in registration guidance issued in March 2023. A federal case on whether a work without a human author can be protected reached the Supreme Court, which declined to hear it in March 2026. The sections below explain what each source says.

Human Authorship Is the Starting Point

The Copyright Office released Part 2 of its report on copyright and artificial intelligence on January 29, 2025. The report covers whether outputs created with generative AI can be protected. It concludes that existing copyright principles are flexible enough to address these works, and it found no case for changing the law to give AI outputs additional protection.

Under that position, generative AI outputs can be protected only where a human author has determined sufficient expressive elements. The test therefore looks at what a person contributed to the finished work, not simply at whether a tool was involved in producing it.

The report concludes that the case has not been made for changes to existing law to protect AI-generated outputs. The report’s earlier part, Part 1, released July 31, 2024, recommended a federal digital replica law. That recommendation concerns digital replicas rather than registration.

Part 3, on generative AI training, was described in the January 2025 report as forthcoming. It addresses the legal implications of training AI models on copyrighted works, including licensing considerations and the allocation of any potential liability. The Office released a pre-publication version on May 9, 2025, in response to congressional inquiries and stakeholder interest. It says a final version will follow, without substantive changes expected in the analysis or conclusions.

Key Date
The Copyright Office released Part 2 of its report on copyright and artificial intelligence on January 29, 2025. The report says prompts alone do not make someone the author of an AI output.

Why Prompts Alone Do Not Make an Applicant the Author

The report states that simply providing prompts does not make someone the author of the output. A founder who types a request into a generator and accepts the result has not, on that fact alone, made the expressive contribution the report describes.

The report describes protection as depending on human creative expression, not on prompting alone. The report points to the human-authored portion as the part that can be protected.

Protection depends on what the person did beyond writing the prompt. The report names creative arrangement or modification of the output as human contributions that can support protection.

Where Human Work Can Still Be Protected

The report says that using AI as an aid in the creative process does not bar copyright. Including AI-generated material inside a larger human-created work also does not bar copyright.

Protection can extend to a human-authored work that is perceptible in an AI output. It can also extend to a human’s creative arrangement or modification of that output. These are the two routes the report names for protection in a work that includes AI material.

What the 2023 Registration Guidance Covers

The Office’s policy statement on registration for works containing AI-generated material was published in the Federal Register at 88 Fed. Reg. 16,190 on March 16, 2023. The statement is titled ‘Copyright Registration Guidance for Works Containing AI-Generated Materials.’ The Office’s AI initiative was launched the same day, according to its AI page.

The AI page also lists a notice of inquiry issued August 30, 2023, published at 88 Fed. Reg. 59,942. Among other items, it lists letters to Congress, including updates dated February 23, 2024, October 30, 2024 and December 16, 2024.

The AI page links the policy statement and lists registration decisions on AI-related works. They include a Registration Decision on Zarya of the Dawn dated February 21, 2023, and Review Board decisions for A Recent Entrance to Paradise (February 14, 2022), Théâtre D’opéra Spatial (September 5, 2023) and SURYAST (December 11, 2023).

The Office’s January 2025 announcement said it plans to supplement its 2023 guidance and update the relevant sections of the Compendium of U.S. Copyright Office Practices. The AI page lists the Compendium, Third Edition, as a related resource.

Under the Office’s position, a prompt alone does not make an applicant the author of what a generator produces.

The Thaler Case Reaches the Supreme Court

The case is Thaler v. Perlmutter, docket number 25-449. The petition came from an opinion of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, which affirmed the denial of registration for an image created by an AI system listed as the sole author. IPWatchdog reports that the opinion, written by Judge Patricia Millett, held that the Copyright Act requires eligible works to be authored in the first instance by a human.

According to IPWatchdog, because the AI system was listed as the sole author, disputes over the amount of human contribution were not at issue.

SCOTUSblog’s case file lists the petition for certiorari as filed October 9, 2025. The federal respondents filed a brief in opposition on January 23, 2026, and the petitioner filed a reply on February 9, 2026. The petition was distributed for a February 27, 2026 conference.

The Supreme Court denied certiorari on March 2, 2026, which means it declined to hear the appeal. The question presented asked whether works produced by an AI system, without a direct, traditional authorial contribution by a natural person, can be copyrighted. The Court’s order did not answer that question, so the issue has no Supreme Court ruling.

What the Office’s Position Means for Registrants

Under the report’s position, the protectable part of a work that includes AI output is the human-authored portion. That portion can be a human work perceptible in the output, or a human’s creative arrangement or modification of it.

The report treats the mere provision of prompts as insufficient for protection.

The Supreme Court has not ruled on the human-authorship question. The Office’s position is set out in the January 2025 report, and its January 2025 announcement says it plans to supplement the 2023 guidance and update the Compendium.

Get more stories like this in your inbox by signing up for the EW newsletter, The Entrepreneurs Weekly’s free digest of founder stories and business news.

Related content
Microsoft Traces Nov. 12 and 13 Microsoft 365 Outage to a Defect in a July Gateway Fix
Microsoft Traces Nov. 12 and 13 Microsoft 365 Outage to a Defect in a July Gateway Fix

Microsoft says a defect in a July fix for its Microsoft 365 gateway servers caused a global outage on Nov. 12 and 13, with Exchange Online hit hardest.

Technology16 November 2026
What the Cyber Resilience Act Requires Within 24 Hours of an Exploited Vulnerability
What the Cyber Resilience Act Requires Within 24 Hours of an Exploited Vulnerability

Reporting duties under the EU Cyber Resilience Act started on 11 September 2026, with a 24-hour early warning and a single EU platform for product makers.

Technology12 November 2026
WorkOS Says an AI-Assisted Intrusion Exposed Customer Contact and Support Data
WorkOS Says an AI-Assisted Intrusion Exposed Customer Contact and Support Data

WorkOS says an AI-assisted intrusion reached business contacts and support records through an internal sales tool. The first confirmed access was 25 October 2026; an update followed on 6 November.

Technology9 November 2026
Cover storyAugust 2026

James Quattrochi

Actor. Producer. Director.

  • InsideStorytelling that endures
  • AlsoPower, legacy, statehood
  • PlusIn the loop
The Entrepreneurs Weekly cover: Manuel AragonThe Entrepreneurs Weekly cover: James Quattrochi
August 2026 edition